An Updated Look at Through-Year Assessment

Oct 28, 2026

New paper updates the national landscape, gathers emerging evidence, provides insights

Three years ago, two of us, with our colleague Will Lorié, published Through-Year Assessment: Ten Key Considerations. We wrote it because states wanted to better understand the risks and opportunities of distributing state testing throughout the year, and the field offered little beyond enthusiasm.

States were asking important questions: How do we produce a defensible summative score by combining results from standardized assessments given from October through May? What supports do teachers need to use information from those within-the-year tests to inform instruction? Will districts give up their own interim assessments if a state provides a through-year program?

Today we are releasing Through-Year Assessment: An Updated National Scan and Research Synthesis. In this paper, we synthesize published evidence to inform these questions. We also describe the current landscape of state through-year programs and outline states’ experiences with through-year assessment over the last 11 years.

Register here for a Dec. 3 webinar, where the co-authors will share insights from their research.

Gathering the Emerging Evidence

Evidence is emerging about these programs, but it is scattered. For example, some of this evidence is tucked into state board of education meeting minutes, pilot reports posted on agency websites, or in federal grant submissions and annual performance reports. There’s also evidence from national conference sessions and technical reports.

pull quote "what is the current landscape of through-year assessment programs, and what evidence exists on their implementation or effectiveness?"

Our paper gathers that body of work—at least the work we could publicly find, through summer 2026—and asks: What is the current landscape of through-year assessment programs, and what evidence exists on their implementation or effectiveness? A key contribution of our paper is that we synthesize this evidence across contexts, with attention to the differences in conditions, programs, and settings. To our knowledge, this is the first time anyone has done that.

Updating the National Picture

Another key contribution of our paper is a current national scan of through-year assessment over the last 11 years, along with related state assessment programs. We provide detailed information about state programs that have operated or are currently operating between spring 2015 and spring 2026.

We distinguish through-year assessment programs from similar programs that people often confuse with them and why these distinctions matter. We focus on three distinct program types: through-year, an assessment approach we call “interim plus,” and state-supported interim assessments.

  • In through-year assessment programs, the results of multiple, within-year assessment administrations are used to produce a single summative score or determination.
  • In an interim-plus assessment program, within-year assessment scores are not used to produce a single summative score or determination, but are state-required or otherwise incentivized and used by the state for some measurement purpose (e.g., inform placement on end-of-year test, develop within-year growth measure connected to the state test) or to directly provide within-year reports to schools for informational purposes (e.g., provide student scale scores and associated performance levels as on the state test). 
  • In state-supported interims, the state funds, provides, requires, and/or guides district use of within-year interim assessments, but the state does not use the results to hold schools accountable or for any measurement purpose (e.g., score students or determine student proficiency, inform placement on end-of-year test, develop within-year growth measure connected to state test).

By characterizing trends in these three types of assessment programs, the scan shows how through-year or interim-plus assessment programs have emerged against a backdrop of broader state engagement in local assessment practices.

Sharing Key Insights

Our synthesis aims to highlight promising evidence and the challenges states have faced in efforts to make state assessments more efficient, coherent, and instructionally useful for educators and students. We hope those interested in, or simply curious about, through-year or interim-plus assessment systems will find our paper useful for understanding what has gone well and what continues to challenge implementation.

We’ve shared four of our six main findings from the research synthesis below. We hope you’ll read the full paper and join the webinar!

  1. Through-year assessment programs are more challenging to implement than “interim-plus” approaches. Only two states, Delaware and Montana, are operating a through-year assessment program today. Four states have discontinued their programs, one has paused, and two are piloting. In comparison, seven states are operating an interim-plus approach, only two have discontinued their programs.
  2. Students prefer a through-year assessment approach. Across Louisiana, Montana, and Texas, students consistently preferred tests distributed throughout the year to a single test at the end.
  3. Building coherence across local curriculum and state assessment has been challenging because it depends on conditions states often do not control. Most states have little influence over local curriculum, which forces a curriculum-agnostic assessment design and removes connections between the assessment and classroom practice. Louisiana represents one example of an approach in which the state directly connected the curriculum to the assessment; however, it could not sustain the program over time.
  4. The field has made progress on addressing some technical challenges with through-year assessment. Implementation challenges remain. States have generated defensible summative scores from within-year results using several different scoring models, and Montana has submitted its program for the federal peer review that all accountability assessments must pass. The difficulties that have closed programs have been cost, staff capacity, curricular variation, and educator trust.

Share: